New York Red Bulls
- 34E. HorvathGK
- 12D. Nealis↓60'
- 2J. Che⚽OG↓71'
- 14J. Bazan
- 59D. Padelford
- 48R. Donkor
- 15A. Mehmeti↓46'
- 37M. Sofo
- 17C. Harper↓60'
- 16J. Hall
- 7C. Cowell↓46'
Substitutes
- 77J. McCarthyGK
- 56M. Dos Santos
- 26T. Parker
- 3J. Marshall-Rutty↑60' for Nealis
- 88Pedro Castro↑71' for Che
- 60S. Kone
- 13E. M. Choupo-Moting↑46' for Cowell
- 11J. Ruvalcaba
Toronto FC4-4-2Coach: Robin Fraser
- 1L. GavranGK
- 19K. Franklin↓28'
- 12Z. Monlouis
- 15N. Gomis
- 3Matheus Pereira
- 7T. Corbeanu↓68'
- 6N. Dorsch
- 21