D.C. United4-3-3Coach: Rene Weiler
- 1S. JohnsonGK
- 5S. Hefti⚽
- 3L. Bartlett
- 15K. Rowles
- 6K. Kurokawa
- 2K. Nono
- 21A. Dozzell
- 23B. Servania↓70'
- 32
Substitutes
- 26A. BonoGK
- 13S. Nealis↑70' for Servania
- 27N. Markovic
- 4M. Peltola
- 48G. Turner
- 40K. Castillo
- 8J. Stroud↑56' for Avilez
- 22N. Ordaz
New York Red Bulls
- 34E. HorvathGK
- 12D. Nealis
- 2J. Che↓57'
- 14J. Bazan
- 59D. Padelford
- 48R. Donkor↓78'
- 15A. Mehmeti↓57'
- 37