New York Red Bulls
- 34E. HorvathGK
- 12D. Nealis
- 26T. Parker↓87'
- 14J. Bazan
- 59D. Padelford↓63'
- 37M. Sofo↓87'
- 60S. Kone↓84'
- 10E. Forsberg
- 11J. Ruvalcaba↓64'
- 13E. M. Choupo-Moting
- 7C. Cowell
Substitutes
- 77J. McCarthyGK
- 6R. Voloder↑87' for Parker
- 45C. Faello↑63' for Padelford
- 80N. Worth↑84' for Kone
- 88Pedro Castro↑64' for Ruvalcaba
- 70A. Rojas↑87' for Sofo
- 66T. Rosborough
St. Louis City SC3-1-4-2Coach: Yoann Damet
- 1R. BurkiGK
- 21D. Polvara
- 32T. Baumgartl
- 27F. Fall
- 8C. Durkin👟
- 6C. Wallem👟
- 24D. Edelman↓85'
- 23