New York City FC4-2-3-1Coach: Pascal Jansen
- 49M. FreeseGK
- 24T. Gray
- 13Thiago Martins
- 6J. Sands
- 2N. Cavallo
- 21A. O'Neill
- 8A. Perea
- 26A. Ojeda↓75'
- 7N. Mercau
- 17H. Wolf↓62'
- 20Luighi↓62'
Substitutes
- 30T. RomeroGK
- 22K. O'Toole
- 34Raul Gustavo
- 23M. Murray
- 35M. Ilenic
- 32J. Shore
- 9B. Traore↑62' for Wolf
- 88M. Jones↑75' for Ojeda
- 16
New York Red Bulls
- 34E. HorvathGK
- 12D. Nealis
- 26T. Parker
- 14J. Bazan
- 56M. Dos Santos↓61'
- 48R. Donkor
- 15A. Mehmeti↓84'
- 37M. Sofo
- 17