Columbus Crew3-4-3Coach: Laurent Courtois
- 28P. SchulteGK
- 31S. Moreira
- 25S. Zawadzki
- 18M. Amundsen
- 26L. Giaccone↓82'
- 50T. Karumanchi
- 20A. Gomes↓83'
- 11B. Lennon
- 10B. Mendez
- 33G. Tapia↓71'
- 8S. Rodriguez↓75'
Substitutes
- 24E. BushGK
- 1N. HagenGK
- 3E. Bailly
- 12C. Ruvalcaba
- 16T. Habroune↑75' for Rodriguez
- 7D. Chambost↑83' for Gomes
- 14A. Sejdic
- 77J. Martinez
New York Red Bulls
- 34E. HorvathGK
- 12D. Nealis
- 26T. Parker
- 14J. Bazan
- 56M. Dos Santos↓66'
- 48R. Donkor⚽
- 15A. Mehmeti↓80'
- 37M. Sofo