New York Red Bulls
- 34E. HorvathGK
- 3J. Marshall-Rutty
- 26T. Parker
- 12D. Nealis↓65'
- 56M. Dos Santos↓46'
- 48R. Donkor
- 15A. Mehmeti
- 10E. Forsberg↓65'
- 7C. Cowell👟×2↓65'
- 16J. Hall⚽×3↓85'
- 11J. Ruvalcaba
Substitutes
- 77J. McCarthyGK
- 4G. Berggren↑65' for Forsberg
- 6R. Voloder
- 2J. Che↑65' for Nealis
- 33R. Mitchell↑85' for Hall
- 79R. Mosquera↑65' for Cowell
- 5O. Valencia↑46' for Dos Santos
Columbus Crew4-4-2Coach: Laurent Courtois
- 28P. SchulteGK
- 31S. Moreira
- 4R. Camacho
- 25S. Zawadzki
- 45O. Presthus↓60'
- 27M. Arfsten⚽
- 20A. Gomes
- 17