FC Cincinnati3-4-1-2Coach: Pat Noonan
- 18R. CelentanoGK
- 24K. Smith↓89'
- 88A. Chirila
- 11S. Gidi
- 20P. Bucha👟↓61'
- 22G. Valenzuela
- 27T. Anunga
- 29B. J. Ramirez Leon↓79'
- 10Evander
- 17K. Mboma↓61'
- 9K. Denkey⚽×2↓79'
Substitutes
- 93F. MrozekGK
- 13E. LouroGK
- 66E. Echenique↑61' for Bucha
- 99A. Jabbari↑79' for Denkey
- 3G. Flores↑89' for Smith
- 37S. Jimenez
- 19S. Chirila
- 16
New York Red Bulls
- 34E. HorvathGK
- 3J. Marshall-Rutty
- 12D. Nealis
- 26T. Parker
- 23J. Masanka Bungi↓46'
- 48R. Donkor↓85'
- 15A. Mehmeti
- 4G. Berggren