Toronto FC3-4-3Coach: Robin Fraser
- 1L. GavranGK
- 12Z. Monlouis↓46'
- 25W. Zimmerman
- 13B. Kuscevic
- 22R. Laryea
- 8J. Cifuentes↓70'
- 21J. Osorio
- 44R. Edwards↓82'
- 10D. Mihailovic👟↓87'
- 17E. Aristizabal↓46'
- 20D. Salloi⚽
Substitutes
- 23W. YarbroughGK
- 11D. Etienne↑46' for Monlouis
- 19K. Franklin↑82' for Edwards
- 6K. Thompson
- 76L. Stefanovic
- 9J. Sargent↑70' for Cifuentes
- 29D. Kerr↑46' for Aristizabal
- 14
New York Red Bulls
- 34E. HorvathGK
- 3J. Marshall-Rutty
- 2J. Che↓90+2'
- 6R. Voloder
- 56M. Dos Santos↓77'
- 15A. Mehmeti
- 11J. Ruvalcaba
- 48R. Donkor