Orlando City SC4-2-3-1Coach: Oscar Pareja
- 71M. CrepeauGK
- 24G. Dorsey↓86'
- 4D. Brekalo
- 57Iago Teodoro↓46'
- 3A. Gomez
- 8B. Ojeda
- 16W. Cartagena↓14'
- 87M. Pasalic↓46'
- 10M. Ojeda
- 14T. Spicer↓76'
- 13D. McGuire
Substitutes
- 12J. OteroGK
- 77I. Angulo↑46' for Pasalic
- 21N. Miller↑46' for Teodoro
- 19Z. Taifi👟↑86' for Dorsey
- 34Y. Tsukada
- 22J. Ellis
- 25C. Guske↑14' for Cartagena
- 29
New York Red Bulls
- 34E. HorvathGK
- 3J. Marshall-Rutty↓65'
- 2J. Che
- 12D. Nealis
- 56M. Dos Santos↓65'
- 48R. Donkor
- 15A. Mehmeti👟↓76'
- 10